Pies from Scafuri Bakery

Come pie with me, let’s pie, let’s pie away.

Pie may be the most perfect dessert. It’s certainly one of our most favorite things to make (though Italian cookies will always win that contest.) We make our pies from scratch with the flakiest, butteriest crust, real fruit, and grandmotherly love. The custard based pies are rich, decadent; a true source of wonder. You can’t go wrong with any of the tried and true staples like pecan, apple and pumpkin. But if you’re looking to shake things up and try something new, we offer some unique flavors to our menu this year, like the balsamic caramel strawberry and butterscotch bourbon chocolate. All of the pies are sure to impress.

And ordering your holiday or everyday pies is as easy as, well, pie. Fill out the form below to place your order. You can also order cookie trays, breads, and specialty cakes for your gathering, just leave a note on the order form or give us a call. We want to make the process simple, quick, and most importantly, delicious. Happy Pie Eating!


Fruit Pies

Custard Pies

Salted Caramel Apple


Cranberry Apple (seasonal)



Mixed Berry

Balsamic Caramel Strawberry 


Pear and Ginger (seasonal)

Peach Blueberry


Classic Pumpkin (seasonal)

Pumpkin with Gingersnap Crust (seasonal)

Lemon Meringue

Sweet Potato Pie

Chocolate Pecan

Chocolate Silk

Butterscotch Bourbon Chocolate (seasonal)

Key Lime

Fill out my online form.

Cookie and Pastry Trays

Italian cookies

Specialty Cakes

seasonal cakes
*The online payment system runs on a different program than the point of sale system in our store. If you would like to apply a gift card or a special discount, please place your order in store or over the phone (312-733-8881) and let us know to apply the gift card or discount.